Item - 2013.SB21.2

Tracking Status

SB21.2 - Application by Clear Channel Outdoor for Variances from Chapter 694 Respecting Five Proposed Third Party Signs at 306 Yonge Street

Decision Type:
ACTION
Status:
Adopted
Ward:
27 - Toronto Centre-Rosedale

Committee Decision

The Sign Variance Committee:

 

1.         Approved the variance requested from §694-26D(1) that a third party sign comply with the applicable provisions of §§ 297-9, 297-10, 297-11 and 297-12 of Chapter 297, Signs, of the Municipal Code of the former City of Toronto, as they applied to the premises municipally known as 306 Yonge Street on the day before Chapter 694 came into effect to allow the issuance of a sign permit authorizing the erection and display of an illuminated third party sign that does not comply with the applicable provisions of §297-12 as the sign has a horizontal measurement of 29.6 metres contrary to the requirement of §297-12.P.(2)(c) either the vertical measurement of the sign or the horizontal measurement of the sign exceed 28.5 metres, a sign face area of 541.7 square metres contrary to the requirement of §297-12.P.(2)(f) that the sign face area of a sign shall not exceed 500 square metres, encroaches 10 metres into the Dundas Street West No Cover Zone contrary to the requirement of §297-12.P.(2)(a) that no sign shall encroach into the Dundas Street West No Cover Zone, results in approximately 119% of the gross surface display area of the media tower will be used for display of third party signs contrary to the requirement of §297-12.P.(7)(a) that no more than 85% of the gross surface display area be utilized for the display of third party signs, may not be erected simultaneously on both the Dundas Street West and Edward Street additional display areas contrary to the requirement of §297-12P.(4)(b) that signs are erected simultaneously on the Dundas Street West and Edward Street additional display areas, and projects beyond the surface of the media tower contrary to the requirement of §297-12.P.(7)(e) that no sign projects beyond the surface of the media tower; on the following conditions:

 

a.         The sign is located on the south facing side of the tower within the area which corresponds with the location bounded by heavy lines and marked as Sign 1 on the diagram attached as Appendix 1 to the report (July 4, 2013) from the Manager, Sign By-law Unit, Toronto Building.

 

b.         The sign contains no more than one sign face as defined by Chapter 694, and the sign face shall be deemed to be a panel for purposes of the application of §297-12.

 

c.         The sign may only display static, mechanical, readograph, electronic static, or electronic moving copy as defined by Chapter 694.

 

d.         The sign shall display copy in accordance with §§694-14I, J.

 

e.         The sign is illuminated in compliance with §694-18.

 

2.         Approved the variance requested from §694-26D(1) that a third party sign comply with the applicable provisions of §§ 297-9, 297-10, 297-11 and 297-12 of Chapter 297, Signs, of the Municipal Code of the former City of Toronto, as they applied to the premises municipally known as 306 Yonge Street on the day before Chapter 694 came into effect to allow the issuance of a sign permit authorizing the erection and display of an illuminated third party sign that does not comply with the applicable provisions of §297-12 as the sign results in approximately 119% of the gross surface display area of the media tower will be used for display of third party signs contrary to the requirement of §297-12.P.(7)(a) that no more than 85% of the gross surface display area be utilized for the display of third party signs; on the following conditions:

 

a.         The sign is located on the south facing side of the tower within the area which corresponds with the location bounded by heavy lines and marked Sign 2 on the diagram attached as Appendix 1 to the report (July 4, 2013) from the Manager, Sign By-law Unit, Toronto Building

 

b.         The sign contains no more than one sign face as defined by Chapter 694, and the sign face shall be deemed to be a panel for purposes of the application of §297-12.

 

c.         The sign may only display static, mechanical, readograph, electronic static or electronic moving copy as defined by Chapter 694.

 

d.         The sign shall display copy in accordance with §§694-14I.

 

3.         Approved the variance requested from the requirement of §694-18E(1) that no sign shall be up-lit and allow the issuance of a sign permit authorizing the erection and display of a sign located on the south facing side of the tower within the area which corresponds with the location bounded by heavy lines and marked Sign 2 on the diagram attached as Appendix 1 to the report (July 4, 2013) from the Manager, Sign By-law Unit, Toronto Building, that is up-lit.

 

4.         Approved the variance requested from §694-26D(1) that a third party sign comply with the applicable provisions of §§ 297-9, 297-10, 297-11 and 297-12 of Chapter 297, Signs, of the Municipal Code of the former City of Toronto, as they applied to the premises municipally known as 306 Yonge Street on the day before Chapter 694 came into effect to allow the issuance of a sign permit authorizing the erection and display of an illuminated third party sign that does not comply with the applicable provisions of §297-12 as the sign results in approximately 119% of the gross surface display area of the media tower will be used for display of third party signs contrary to the requirement of §297-12.P.(7)(a) that no more than 85% of the gross surface display area be utilized for the display of third party signs; on the following conditions:

 

a.         The sign is located on the south facing side of the tower within the area which corresponds with the location bounded by heavy lines and marked as Sign 3 on the diagram attached as Appendix 1 to the report (July 4, 2013) from the Manager, Sign By-law Unit, Toronto Building.

 

b.         The sign contains no more than one sign face as defined by Chapter 694, and the sign face shall be deemed to be a panel for purposes of the application of §297-12.

 

c.         The sign may only display static copy as defined by Chapter 694.

 

5.         Approved the variance requested from the requirement of §694-18E(1) that no sign shall be up-lit and allow the issuance of a sign permit authorizing the erection and display of a sign located on the south facing side of the tower within the area which corresponds with the location bounded by heavy lines and marked Sign 3 on the diagram attached as Appendix 1 to the report (July 4, 2013) from the Manager, Sign By-law Unit, Toronto Building, that is up-lit.

 

6.         Approved the variance requested from §694-26D(1) that a third party sign comply with the applicable provisions of §§ 297-9, 297-10, 297-11 and 297-12 of Chapter 297, Signs, of the Municipal Code of the former City of Toronto, as they applied to the premises municipally known as 306 Yonge Street on the day before Chapter 694 came into effect to allow the issuance of a sign permit authorizing the erection and display of an illuminated third party sign that does not comply with the applicable provisions of §297-12 as the sign results in approximately 119% of the gross surface display area of the media tower will be used for display of third party signs contrary to the requirement of §297-12.P.(7)(a) that no more than 85% of the gross surface display area be utilized for the display of third party signs; on the following conditions:

 

a.         The sign is located on the south facing side of the tower within the area which corresponds with the location bounded by heavy lines and marked as Sign 4 on the diagram attached as Appendix 1 to the report (July 4, 2013) from the Manager, Sign By-law Unit, Toronto Building.

 

b.         The sign contains no more than one sign face as defined by Chapter 694, and the sign face shall be deemed to be a panel for purposes of the application of §297-12.

 

c.         The sign may only display static, mechanical, readograph, electronic static or electronic moving copy as defined by Chapter 694;

 

d.         The sign shall display copy in accordance with §§694-14I, J.

 

e.         The sign is illuminated in compliance with §694-18.

 

7.         Approved the variance requested from §694-26D(1) that a third party sign comply with the applicable provisions of §§ 297-9, 297-10, 297-11 and 297-12 of Chapter 297, Signs, of the Municipal Code of the former City of Toronto, as they applied to the premises municipally known as 306 Yonge Street on the day before Chapter 694 came into effect to allow the issuance of a sign permit authorizing the erection and display of an illuminated third party sign that does not comply with the applicable provisions of §297-12 as the sign encroaches 10 metres into the top portion of the Edward Street No Cover Zone contrary to the requirement of §297-12.P.(3)(a)that no sign shall not encroach into the Edward Street No Cover Zone, results in approximately 119% of the gross surface display area of the media tower will be used for display of third party signs contrary to the requirement of §297-12.P.(7)(a) that no more than 85% of the gross surface display area be utilized for the display of third party signs, may not be erected simultaneously on both the Dundas Street West and Edward Street additional display areas contrary to the requirement of §297-12.P.(4)(b) that signs are erected simultaneously on the Dundas Street West and Edward Street additional display areas, and projects beyond the surface of the media tower contrary to the requirement of §297-12.P.(7)(e) that no sign projects beyond the surface of the media  tower; on the following conditions:

 

a.         The sign is located on the north facing side of the tower within the area which corresponds with the location bounded by heavy lines and marked as Sign 5 on the diagram attached as Appendix 1 to the report (July 4, 2013) from the Manager, Sign By-law Unit, Toronto Building.

 

b.         The sign may only display static copy as defined by Chapter 694.

 

c.         The sign shall display copy in accordance with §§694-14 I, J.

 

d.         The sign is illuminated in compliance with §694-18.

 

e.         The sign may contain no more than twelve sign faces as defined by Chapter 694, and each sign face shall be deemed to be a panel for purposes of the application of §297-12.

 

f.          The area of any sign face shall not be less than 72 square metres.

 

g.         The area of any sign face shall not exceed 648 square metres.

 

h.         No sign face shall have a horizontal measurement which exceeds 29.6 metres.

 

i.          No sign face shall have a vertical measurement that exceeds more than 27.0 metres.

 

j.          The total sign face area of the sign shall not exceed 930 square metres.

Decision Advice and Other Information

The Chair noted that at the previous meeting on July 9, 2013, the Applicant had waived his right to address the Committee. On motion by the Chair, the Committee amended the order of business to allow the Applicant to address the Committee in support of his application.

Origin

(July 4, 2013) Report from the Manager, Sign By-law Unit, Toronto Building

Summary

This report reviews and makes recommendations on a request by the Applicant, Clear Channel Outdoor, to erect and display five third party signs displaying a mix of static and electronic moving sign copy on an existing media tower located at 306 Yonge Street in the Dundas Square Special Sign District.

 

This report recommends approval of variances required from Chapter 694-26D(1) and 694-18E(1) to permit the proposed signs to display third party sign copy with an area of 119% of the surface area of the media tower,  to allow one sign to exceed the maximum permitted sign face area by 41.7 square metres; to allow two of the proposed signs to project beyond the surface of the media tower and into the Dundas Street West and Edward Street No Cover Zones; to allow for signs to not be erected simultaneously on the Dundas Street West and Edward Street display areas; to allow two of the proposed signs to be up-lit; and, to allow one of the signs to have a maximum width of 29.6 metres.

Background Information

(July 4, 2013) Report and Attachments 1-3 from the Manager, Sign By-law Unit, Toronto Building - Application by Clear Channel Outdoor for Variances from Chapter 694 respecting Five Proposed Third Party Signs at 306 Yonge Street
https://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2013/sb/bgrd/backgroundfile-60229.pdf
(June 24, 2013) Report from the Manager, Sign By-law Unit, Toronto Building - Application by Clear Channel Outdoor for Variances from Chapter 694 of the Municipal Code, Signs, General Respecting a Proposed Third Party Sign at 595 Bay Street (306 Yonge Street) - Notice of Pending Report
https://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2013/sb/bgrd/backgroundfile-60228.pdf

Communications

(July 8, 2013) E-mail from J. Ken Rutherford (SB.Main.SB21.2.1)
(August 30, 2013) Letter from Councillor Mark Grimes (SB.New.SB21.2.2)
https://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2013/sb/comm/communicationfile-39488.pdf

Speakers

Paul Seaman, Vice President, Real Estate and Public Affairs, Clear Channel Outdoor
Ted Van Vliet, Manager, Sign By-law Unit, Toronto Building

Motions

1 - Motion to Set Committee Rule moved by Tracey Hamilton (Carried)

That the order of business be changed to allow the Applicant to address the Committee.


2 - Motion to Adopt Item moved by Morris Jacob Winer (Carried)
Source: Toronto City Clerk at www.toronto.ca/council